O Wait. It is.
Edited by underground comic lord Chris Ware, McSweeney's 13 promises a treasure trove of other alternative artistry from all the majors, Daniel Clowes, Joe Sacco, Richard Sala, Charles Burns, Adrian Tomine, Joe Matt, Art Spiegelman, Crumb, Seth, Kaz... with late sketches from Charles Schulz and George Herriman. The list is a remarkable roster of heavy-hitting Raw alums and a nice cross section of talent across the alternative comics realm.
The volume is exquisite, and there's really few other words to describe it. It's got all the quirky attention to detail that people love in both Chris Ware and McSweeney's. The hardcover volume, reminiscent of the Acme Novelty Datebook, is wrapped in a funny-pages-of-yore mock-up of Chris Ware "round guy" comics (its reverse side is the contributor list). Hidden within the folds of the paper are a pair of mini-comics, rounding out a full representation of underground comics formats.
So, that's why I was ecstatic as I left Chicago Comics with the heavy volume at my side. And maybe I had gotten my hopes up, I'll give you that but...
Blegh.
The volume is certainly nice, and anyone who doesn't frequent the work of the artists I've listed above will probably find it rewarding. It's also a great collector's piece... your grandkids (or grandkids' grandkids for those not in my personal demographic) will look at it and yearn for the days when art was on paper.
The most upsetting thing is that the volume is for the most part, excerpts from recent longer works. Sacco's piece is from his tremendous The Fixer released last fall, Tomine brings his latest Optic Nerve to the table, Art Spiegelman reiterates the mess that is "In the Shadow of No Towers", Ware's work will be no stranger to those who read the regular Acme Novelty series in alt-weeklies, and it continues to the point that you're startled when you see somethign without the words "excerpt from" in front of it. Bless Jeffrey Brown for his unpublished pile of sketchbooks that are always releasing fresh pieces. If this wasn't comics... if this was, for instance, an anthology of "short stories", this thing would be torn apart for what it's trying to present itself as. There is little new here for those that would be most interested in it. I'd think McSweeney's would have the clout to get some original or rare work from this line-up. I'd be wrong.